DAILY SNEWS / ZYN Black Menthol, Reviewed: 14 vs 16.5 mg, and How It Differs From Menthol Ice

ZYN Black Menthol, Reviewed: 14 vs 16.5 mg, and How It Differs From Menthol Ice

Zack F 4 min read
Can of ZYN Black Menthol nicotine pouches

ZYN Black Menthol is the newest ZYN in the store. We added it in early November, and it's a mint-forward menthol in a black can: peppermint with a note of eucalyptus, sold in 14 and 16.5 mg slims with 20 pouches a can, at the same price either way. ZYN recommends both strengths for experienced pouch users, and I agree with that. This review covers how it tastes, what separates the 14 from the 16.5, and where it sits next to Menthol Ice and Cool Mint.

What ZYN Black Menthol tastes like

Peppermint comes first, and it's a proper mint flavor rather than the straight menthol of Menthol Ice. Then the eucalyptus shows up behind it, and that's where most of the cold comes from. Eucalyptus has a cooling, slightly herbal edge, and it gives this can a different kind of cold than the soft cool of Cool Mint: deeper and a little drier. There's no sweetness to speak of and no fruit. If you've had a strong eucalyptus lozenge you know the general idea, though this is cleaner than that, and the mint stays in charge the whole way through.

It's a slim pouch, the same shape as Cool Mint Slim and Menthol Ice, so it sits the same way and lasts longer than a Mini would, which suits a can at this strength.

14 mg vs 16.5 mg

The flavor is the same at both strengths. The difference is nicotine. The 14 is the only ZYN we stock at 14 mg, which puts it between Blackcurrant Frost at 13.5 and the 16.5s. If 11 mg is your everyday strength, the 14 is the one to get, and ZYN says the same thing on its side. It's a real step up from an 11 mg Cool Mint Slim without being a jump.

The 16.5 ties Menthol Ice as the strongest ZYN we sell, and it's in the Extra Strong tier on our strength chart (16 mg and up). It feels a bit colder than the 14, but that's the nicotine, since the recipe doesn't change. Get it only if you already use 14 or 16.5 comfortably. If you're coming up from 11 you may end up here eventually, and there's no reason to rush it.

Against ZYN Menthol Ice

This is the comparison people ask about, because both are strong ZYN menthols in a slim. Menthol Ice is straight menthol: no mint flavor, nothing sweet, cold from the first minute and for a long time after, a bit like a cough drop without the medicinal taste. Black Menthol tastes like mint, with the eucalyptus doing the cooling. So Menthol Ice is the colder can and Black Menthol is the one with more flavor. Menthol Ice comes in 11, 13.5 and 16.5, so if you want a strong ZYN menthol at 14, Black Menthol is the only option, and that alone will sell a lot of cans.

Against the rest of the store

  • ZYN Cool Mint Slim, 9 or 11 mg: clean peppermint with a soft cool and less nicotine. If Cool Mint at 11 has stopped doing it for you, Black Menthol at 14 is the natural next step without leaving ZYN.
  • VELO Freezing Peppermint, 14 or 17 mg: peppermint, then a deep menthol cold, in a moist slim that starts fast. Freezing is colder, and Black Menthol has more going on in the flavor. The two 14s are a fair match, and our peppermint roundup covers the VELO side.
  • White Fox Full Charge, 16 mg: dry, slow and long. Full Charge builds gradually where Black Menthol at 16.5 gets going sooner, and our Full Charge review explains the long release.

Who it's for

ZYN regulars at 11 who want more strength and a colder, less sweet mint. People who found Menthol Ice too plain and want actual mint flavor in a strong can. VELO Freezing users curious about a ZYN at the same strength. Skip it if you're on the 3 or 6 mg Minis, or if eucalyptus isn't your thing, because there's no hiding it in this can. And if you want the coldest ZYN, that's still Menthol Ice (our guide to the cold words on cans explains why cold and strength are separate things).

It's on our ZYN mint page and our ZYN slim page, with the 16.5 on our strongest pouches page too. Like every ZYN we sell, it's the European can, and our European ZYN page explains how that differs from the US version. We ship within the US to adults 21 or over.

Quick answers

What does ZYN Black Menthol taste like?

Peppermint first, with a note of eucalyptus that gives it a deeper, drier cold than Cool Mint. It's a mint-forward menthol, not straight menthol like Menthol Ice.

What strengths does ZYN Black Menthol come in?

14 and 16.5 mg per pouch, both in a slim pouch with 20 pouches a can, at the same price. ZYN recommends both strengths for experienced pouch users.

ZYN Black Menthol 14 or 16.5?

The 14 if 11 mg is your usual strength. The 16.5 only if you already use 14 or stronger comfortably; it ties Menthol Ice as the strongest ZYN we sell.

Is ZYN Black Menthol the same as ZYN Menthol Ice?

No. Menthol Ice is straight menthol with no mint flavor, and it's the colder of the two. Black Menthol is peppermint with eucalyptus, so it has more flavor and a little less cold.

WARNING: This product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.